Company Products
Indoor Outdoor 48 V tracks All products Museums and places of worship Showcases and display cases
Solutions
Museums and showcasesJewellery and watch storesShops and boutiquesWine shops and cellarsOffices and schoolsGardens and outdoor
Tools
Track configurator Display case calculator LED wiring guide (IT) CTO/CTB gel calculator (IT)
Articles
Lighting a paintingCRI 90 and R9 SKILL, the case that measures light
Quote List (0) Private Area Contacts
IT EN FR DE
Private Area Quote List 0
EN

We use anonymous technical and analytical cookies. Info

Rotate your phone to landscape to read the tables better.

CRI 90 and R9

The colour rendering figure on every catalogue does not tell you whether reds will look red. How it is calculated, what it hides and what to really ask for.

In catalogues CRI has become a tick box: 80 on cheap products, 90 on those that want to look professional, 97 on museum ones. That number alone does not tell you whether reds will look red, and in lighting artworks, textiles, wood, food and people, reds are half the job.

1. How CRI is really calculated

Eight standard colour samples are lit, virtually, by the light under test and by a reference light of the same colour temperature. The shift of each sample is converted into a score from 0 to 100 and averaged: that average is Ra, the CRI. Two consequences: the eight samples are pastel, none of them is a full red, green or blue; and it is an average, so a serious error on one colour hides behind seven good results. Six supplementary samples, R9 to R14 (saturated red, yellow, green, blue, skin tone, foliage), are not part of Ra.

2. Why red is the weak point of LEDs

A white LED is a blue chip around 450 nm under a phosphor that converts part of the blue into broad yellow light. The resulting spectrum has a narrow blue peak and a poor tail in deep red, 630-700 nm. Filling that gap takes a second, red phosphor: it costs money and it costs lumens, because the light is emitted where the eye is less sensitive. That is why Ra 80 is the mass market default.

3. What high rendering costs in lumens

RenderingRelative lumensTypical R9Where it makes sense
Ra 80100%0 - 20Warehouses, car parks
Ra 9085 - 90%30 - 60Quality offices, shops, restaurants
Ra 9575 - 82%70 - 90Museums, galleries, fashion, jewellery
Ra 97+70 - 78%90 - 98Restoration, photography, graphic arts

Typical orders of magnitude at equal chip, current and colour temperature; the LED datasheet is what counts. On a museum spotlight of a few watts the loss is irrelevant on the energy bill.

4. What to write in a specification

Colour rendering referred to the complete luminaire:
- Ra ≥ 90 (≥ 95 for polychrome works, textiles, skin tones);
- R9 ≥ 50 (≥ 90 for museums);
- colour tolerance within 3 SDCM (MacAdam ellipses), so that two spotlights side by side have the same white;
- where possible: TM-30 with Rf ≥ 85 and Rg between 95 and 110.

"CRI above 90" alone protects from nothing, because a luminaire with R9 at zero also meets it.

5. TM-30: two numbers that describe LEDs better

IES TM-30 uses 99 colour samples from real objects and gives Rf, fidelity (above 85 good, above 90 excellent), and Rg, saturation (95-110 natural; 115 is a light that "colours", nice in a shop and wrong in a museum). Its 16-sector graphic shows in which colour area the light errs.

6. The practical test, in thirty seconds

  1. Two luminaires side by side, same declared colour temperature, same lux level.
  2. Light a saturated red object and the back of your hand.
  3. With low R9 red turns orange-brown and skin grey or yellowish; with high R9 red is full and skin looks alive.

The comparison must be simultaneous: in sequence the eye adapts and notices almost nothing.

7. And conservation?

Photochemical damage depends on how much energy reaches the work and how far it is shifted towards blue and UV. At equal colour temperature, Ra 80 and Ra 90 LEDs have similar damage per lumen: colour temperature and the blue peak matter more than CRI. To choose a museum luminaire you need the LED spectrum, from which damage per lumen is calculated (CIE 157). See the museum lighting guide and how to light a painting.

8. Frequent questions

What is the difference between CRI 80 and CRI 90?

CRI (or Ra) is the average of how faithfully eight sample colours appear under the light tested compared with a reference light. With Ra 80 the shift is visible on coloured surfaces: slightly washed out colours and grey skin tones. With Ra 90 it falls below the threshold most people notice. In practice Ra 80 is enough for a warehouse, Ra 90 is the minimum for quality shops and offices, Ra 95 is the standard for museums and galleries.

What is R9?

It is the rendering index of saturated red, one of six supplementary samples (R9 to R14) not included in general CRI. White LEDs, made with a blue chip and yellow phosphor, lack deep red between 630 and 700 nm: a luminaire can declare Ra 90 with R9 close to zero. Reds look dull, wood turns grey and skin looks unhealthy.

Which R9 should be specified?

R9 at least 50 for quality commercial spaces, at least 90 for museums, galleries and portraits. Ask for it in writing together with CRI, because it is not part of the general index and few catalogues publish it.

Does a high CRI use more energy?

Yes: raising red needs a phosphor emitting where the eye is less sensitive. At equal watts you typically lose 10-15% of lumens from Ra 80 to Ra 90 and 20-25% at Ra 95-97. On a museum spotlight of a few watts the energy difference is irrelevant; for the artwork it is decisive.

Are CRI and TM-30 the same thing?

No. CRI uses eight low saturation samples. IES TM-30 uses 99 samples and gives two numbers: Rf, average fidelity, and Rg, average saturation (above 100 the light saturates, below 100 it mutes). It describes LEDs better; ask for both.

How can CRI be checked without instruments?

It cannot be measured, but two luminaires side by side, at the same colour temperature, on a red object and the back of the hand, show the difference between Ra 80 and Ra 90 with high R9 even to the naked eye, as long as the comparison is simultaneous. A certified value needs a spectrometer.

Sources. CRI per CIE 13.3, TM-30 per IES TM-30, photochemical damage per CIE 157:2004. Lumen losses and R9 values in the table are typical orders of magnitude of commercial LEDs.
See the museum spotlights Ask for the LED data